Seized by Secularism

Thursday, 28 Apr 2011

Like Europe, the United States has now been “seized by secularism,” Newt Gingrich warned at the National Catholic Prayer Breakfast on Wednesday. As evidence of the replacement of Christianity with secularism, the former House Speaker cited the following: replacing Anno Domini (A.D.) with the Common Era (C.E.), banning school prayer, striking out “one nation under God” in the Pledge of Allegiance, and the court battle over the Mojave Desert Cross that commemorates World War I veterans. Gingrich explained how “secularist fanaticism” encouraged him to join the Church of Rome in 2008. He asked the audience to imagine themselves as the pope, facing a culture that tears down crosses and bans school prayer.

At the same time, Fox News commentator Bill O’Reilly was ruffled over the current TIME cover story, reporting the denial of hell by evangelical pastor Rob Bell in his book, Love Wins. O’Reilly said we need hell for the Pol Pots, Lenins, and Hitlers of the world, though he cited official Roman Catholic statements about those who try sincerely to do good as unlikely candidates for hell. So Ghandi is in, but Hitler is out. Ah, so good people go to heaven and bad people go to hell—and, of course, I’m a good person. If this isn’t a secularization of the Christian faith, I don’t know what is.

Also in the last couple days, MSNBC commentator Lawrence O’Donnell took on Rusch Limbaugh for distorting Jesus’s teaching. After a tirade against the Left for using Jesus as a mascot for socialism, Limbaugh used Jesus as a mascot for capitalism. Not “What Would Jesus Do?”, but “What Would Jesus Take?”, is the question to ask. And the answer, of course, is nothing. Jesus was against high taxes. Au contraire, O’Donnell responds, quoting Jesus’s conversation with the rich young ruler and the separation of the sheep and goats in Matthew 25. For his part, O’Donnell invokes Jesus for a progressive income tax structure.

So what do all of these stories have in common? Lots of things come to mind, but I’ll mention two. First, all of these stories point up the remarkable ignorance of Scripture and a consequent inability to do anything more with it than find quotable sound-bites for positions that one would have if Jesus had never lived. Second, they suggest that there is indeed a creeping secularism that is threatening vital Christianity. However, I would suggest that the kind of Christianity that many worried souls have in mind is not really that different from creeping secularism.

In the 1950s, C. S. Lewis was asked by Decision magazine whether he was concerned about the “de-Christianizing” of the West, especially Europe. Lewis replied, “I’m not really qualified to speak to the question of the culture, but there is definitely a de-Christianizing of the church.” It’s one thing for Christian churches to lose their cultural influence. Fusing Christ with a particular civilization is already a gross distortion of the faith. Nevertheless, “Christendom” is over, regardless of whether you think it was a good or bad idea in the first place. Benign prayers to an unkown god in public schools, apart from the Mediator, is already a capitulation to secularism. Who cares whether crosses no longer dominate national memorials where Jews, Moslems, Buddhists, and atheists are buried? The question is whether the cross is proclaimed in our churches.

Maybe “fanatical secularists” who are so nervous about public expressions of faith have something to worry about, when burning Qur’ans and using Jesus for whatever left-wing or right-wing policy become the most familiar presence of religion in public life. Maybe it’s time for us to stop taking God’s name in vain and begin again to be Christians in a pagan culture.



  • 28 Apr 2011
    Peter Widmer says:

    “The question is whether the cross is proclaimed in our churches.” Yes, Mike, we have to proclaim cross and resurrection!

    Yet I am not alone, for my Father is with me. “I have told you these things, so that in me you may have peace. In this world you will have trouble. But take heart! I have overcome the world.”
    New International Version: Joh 16,32-33

  • 29 Apr 2011
    Rev. R Crabtree says:

    Speaking as an American currently serving as a minister in secularized Scotland, all I can say is a heart-felt AMEN to all that I’ve read here.
    Ministering in a culture that is completely given over to secular-humanism has taught me a valuable lesson – you either communicate the gospel consistently, clearly and compellingly or your church dies.
    In my experience this is the reality of Church-life in the UK and I sense that one day (perhaps soon) this will be the reality in the American-church as well… Because of this I long for the church in America to get to grips with “what it believes and why.”
    Of course understanding and articulating doctrine in a thoughtful and compelling fashion would be a major change for much of American Evangelicalism which is largely focused on its politics, its pet-issues and its potlucks in the church fellowship hall… (Special music by Brother Dave and the Ratliff family to follow.)
    Why is this??????
    How have we gotten here????
    Frankly, I’d rather be associated with the gospel than with a potluck any day.

  • 29 Apr 2011
    Seized By Secularism « The Reformed Traveler says:

    […] by Michael Horton […]

  • 29 Apr 2011
    Paul Grace says:

    WWJT — What would Jesus take? That is funny! Given the price of oil and gas, we should probably also revisit the question, “What Would Jesus Drive?”

    I think that the pundits on both sides of the aisle are looking for reasons to blame the pervasive open sinfulness that has become socially acceptable. I’m not sure whether people are really any more or less sinful in their day to day lives than they were in the 1950’s. Regardless, all are still under the power sin.

    Further, there are probably more Christians than we realize that believe it is imperative that the Gospel be proclaimed. However, to many this is really just a means to an end, the end being a better society. But we don’t know what God intends for this country or any other. It may well be that despite our best efforts to preach the gospel, brazen sinfulness abounds even more.

    I pray that the motivation to preach the gospel is not so much the betterment of society but rather the Great Commission.

  • 30 Apr 2011
    Leon Cunningham says:

    A hardy amen!

  • 04 May 2011
    Bob says:

    This article didn’t come close to proving the point it was meant to.
    The only thing that has happned is that the church has lost cultural influence which is a good thing- religion is inherenty authoritarian. There is still a long way to go though: stem cell research, abortion rights, and a areligious political enviroment all aren’t here because of religious influences. Three people were quoted which is just like having a survey of just three people. It doesn’t mean anything. Wishing for the right to impose religion isn’t a right its just a desire to oppress.

  • 06 May 2011
    Seized by Secularism by Michael Horton | as i travel thru ThisPilgrimLand says:

    […] Michaels Hortons Seized by Secularism […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Email Address
Forgot Password?
Signup for an account now