The familiar lines of Samuel Stone’s hymn The Church’s One Foundation have doubtlessly been in the minds of all those who long to see a unified Reformed witness–particularly in these days of celebration around the five hundredth anniversary of John Calvin’s birth. Such hopes seem to have been revived among evangelicals in the Church of Scotland recently. News from the Kirk is that evangelicals are considering whether or not they can convince the Free Church to give up exclusive psalmody in an effort to open the doors to potentially hundreds of ministers and churches after the Church’s approval over the weekend to the transfer of a gay minister to a new church.

Why must every effort at reunion require one or more of the merging partners to lose their unique characteristics? Is there a way for the evangelicals in the Church of Scotland to have formal communion with the Free Church without the Free Church giving up their long history of and principled stand on exclusive psalmody?

In 2005 Modern Reformation was proud to feature an article by W. Robert Godfrey titled A Reformed Dream. In the article Godfrey envisions a day when each current denomination is distinguished by its practices or ethnic heritage into Synods while at the same time gathered together into a worldwide general assembly according to its common confession of faith. For more on Godfrey’s vision see